counter for tumblr

On this Day in 2008: The Immaculate Deception begins


Today is exactly 4 years to the day that George Anthony murdered Caylee Anthony. Here’s an excerpt from my September 2011 post – “Immaculate Deception: The Untold Story of Caylee Marie Anthony”

June 16th 2008:

On the morning of June 16th 2008, between (6am-8am), George is in bed, and Caylee (having just woken and found her mom still sleeping and Cindy already left for work) she goes on her usual early morning walkabout – this time finishing up into bed with George. Nothing out of the ordinary with that in itself – but we’re dealing with George Anthony here.

I’m not going into specifics now, but within a few minutes of Caylee climbing into his bed, he starts abusing her like he’s done many times before (and just like he’s done with Casey since she was 8 years old). Only onthis occasion, for reasons only he knows, he gets a little too excited and forceful.

Caylee is screaming out by this time, so in an effort to keep her quiet (and not wake Casey up) he pushes her face into the pillow and carries on oblivious.

After “doing his thing” with Caylee for a while longer, he suddenly notices Caylee has stopped breathing. She’s suffocated.


Now – had Caylee really drowned in the pool and had George NOT been abusing her that same morning, I firmly believe a 911 call would have been made… and there’s a possibility Caylee may have survived, and this whole unfortunate incident would have been finished with way back in June 2008.

But you see… THAT couldn’t happen.

George, not being able to keep his damn hands to himself with either Casey OR Caylee well & truly took that option out of the equation.

Bear with me here.

So, right after Caylee suffocated (in my theory of events)… right at that precise moment in time… George had 2 clear options open to him, but very little time to decide.

His 2 options were as follows:

Option #1: George CALLS 911 to try and SAVE his granddaughter, while at the same time knowing only too well that his molestation will be discovered, and he’ll therefore be duly ostracized by the local community, finish up in prison, and get to spend the rest of his days on the sex offenders register – BUT Caylee lives.


Option #2: George DOES NOT call 911 – he decides that Option #1 isn’t so appealing after all – so instead he decides to SAVE HIS OWN SORRY ASS by carrying Caylee outside and slipping her into the pool, therefore making it LOOK like an accident OR an event caused by someone else’s negligence. In this option, unfortunately, Caylee dies.

I believe George went for Option #2.

Remember: This is only my own personal theory of events. I was obviously not there at the time… but nevertheless I believe Caylee tragically died while being molested by George Anthony. (Note: as Caylee’s death occurred during the commission of a felony (i.e. while GA was sexually abusing her), that’s classed as Murder (rather than aggravated manslaughter), regardless of the perpetrator’s intent).

The “Discovery” of Caylee’s Body:

Straight after George has put Caylee in the pool, he heads straight back to bed like nothing happened.

At some point within the next couple of hours, Casey wakes up – but there’s no sign of Caylee.

She goes into George’s bedroom, wakes him up and asks him “Where’s Caylee?”

“How should I know? I thought she was with YOU!” he yells back at her. Even at this early stage he’s already distanced himself from having anything whatsoever to do with Caylee’s death.

At this point they both decide to start frantically searching the house and garden, front and back and everywhere in-between. Shortly after that, George finds Caylee in the pool.

He shouts Casey.

She comes rushing out of the house and into the back garden. There she sees George… stood there… holding a lifeless Caylee in his arms.

Just like a good actor, George has proved he can turn the waterworks on whenever he needs to (just like during the trial) – and he does that now.

Casey goes hysterical as you’d expect.

“Oh my God! Call 911!” she yells (or words to that effect).

But George is having none of it.

He fights back his crocodile tears and tells Casey: “NO! NO! It’s too late for that. It’s too late! She’s drowned! She’s gone!”

What he really means is: “No, I can’t… because if they come they’ll find out I’ve been abusing her!” –– but he obviously doesn’t say that.

This is where George Anthony is in his element.

At the very moment Casey needs SUPPORT from her father, he takes the opposite route – the selfish uncaring old bastard that he is.

“Look what you’ve done!” he yells at Casey. “Look what you’ve done! This is ALL YOUR FAULT for NOT BEING THERE for Caylee… for not watching her! YOU CAUSED THIS! YOU LET THIS HAPPEN! Oh my God, you have no fucking idea! Your mother will NEVER FORGIVE YOU for doing this, and you’re gonna GO TO JAIL FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIFE FOR CHILD NEGLECT!”

And with that, George Anthony’s big cover up (the “Immaculate Deception”) begins….

CLICK HERE to read “Immaculate Deception: The Untold Story of Caylee Marie Anthony”

R.I.P. Caylee Marie Anthony (August 9, 2005 – June 16, 2008) – Gone but never forgotten…

Feel free to leave your comments below,


  1. I am glad you posted this, SJ. However, it hardly offsets that damage done by the show about Casey that aired tonight on the BIO network. It is very frustrating looking at such one-sided presentations.

    • Hi EAH, No probs. The post was meant more as a reminder. I never waste my time watching ill-informed half-assed TV shows about Casey – so I can’t really comment on the Bio network BS or the non-existent damage it caused.

      • Well it is damage. To me, everything that reinforces the myth of Casey Anthony is bad.

        • Hi EAH. I hear you loud & clear, for sure… and that’s exactly why it’s always better to concentrate on the positives and not waste any energy on the negatives.

  2. RIP sweet Caylee!

  3. This is so sad and it angers me Caylee had to leave this earth the way she did among many many children in this world. No child deserves any of this ;.(

  4. Harry N says:

    I’ve come to believe that the only way that Casey will be allowed to move on, and that Caylee will be allowed to rest in peace, is for George to be fully exposed to the world. In a way that no one can deny Casey’s innocence, even Nancy Grace. I pray that will happen eventually.

  5. I have a question not directly related to this thread @ SJ or anyone who can answer. The psych evals that proved that Casey isn’t a sociopath or a psycho, did the jury have access to them? I know the drs did not testify in court, but was the info available to the jury?

  6. SJ – Is it true that Casey is looking to publish her journal into a book? It’s all over the web. I hope so. But, it’s probably just more BS to keep Casey in the news.

    • Hi Jon, It looks very much like a filler story from Radar-Online – but it’s very likely that Casey will be writing a book at some point, although it’ll happen when it happens.

  7. George reminds me of the Father in the movie The General’s Daughter with John Travolta. And, Casey reminds me of the Daughter.

  8. Marilyn C. says:

    Hi Everyone…I’ve been out sick for a while…but tonight as I am laying here watching Sandusky getting a GUILTY verdict for molesting those poor guys…..I only wish George Anthony could be right behind him! Good night all

  9. Hi Marilyn that’s exactly what I thought too! These sick bastards need to pay for what they do!

  10. … and yet I really think Sandusky is in a different category – a mass molester!

  11. SJ,

    I have a question for you. I had seen the transcript of the interview with a member of Casey’s family in Texas who alleged that Cindy told them that Jose’s theory about George & Caylee is true. I dismissed this as a hoax just for lack of any corroboration. Do you in fact believe that Cindy made remarks along these lines to family members in Texas?

  12. Hmmm don’t be surprised once Jose Baez’s book is out we’ll hear another suicide attempt from George. Skip the suicide attempt…CONFESS! Once the truth is out people will still be in denial.

  13. George

    Don’t wait til the truth comes out. Be a man for once in your life. Give Casey back her life so she can move on and grieve for Caylee. You owe it to her. Please George do the right thing.

  14. It looks as though Jose goes into considerable deatails about George’s molestation of Casey and the role it played in her obvious psychological problems. If the police hadn’t fixated on Casey’s lies they may have realized they were dealing with a victim and not a perpetrator. Hopefully Jose’s book will change some minds, and put the media and the public’s focus on George. I’m damn sure his book will be more accurate than Ashton’s cynical, sel-serving screed, which was designed to fire up the lynch mob against Casey and get him elected SA.

    • All the Haters like George and feel sorry for him. Many people thought Jerry Sandusky was a nice guy until they learned the truth.

Speak Your Mind